7 Common Mistakes New Dungeon Masters Make (And How to Fix Them)

You agreed to run the game, and now your brain feels like a browser with forty tabs open: the world, the plot, NPC voices, the rules, and whether anyone is actually having fun. That weight is normal. So are the mistakes. Most first-time DMs hit the same bumps because the job is broad, not because they’re bad at it.

Each mistake below comes with what it looks like at the table, a specific fix, and a line you can actually say. You don’t need to fix all seven at once. Pick one, try it next session, and see how it lands.

A quick label: the rules sections cite the Player’s Handbook (PHB) and Dungeon Master’s Guide (DMG), 2014 and 2024. Everything else is advice from running a weekly table, not official rules.

1. You prepped a novel; they chose a side quest

What it looks like: You wrote out Act One. The party ignores the mayor, follows a strange dog into the woods, and you either panic or push them back with an NPC who won’t take no for an answer. Players feel that. The world shrinks and their choices stop mattering.

The fix: Prep situations, not scenes that must happen. For each session, write down:

When the party wanders, your villain keeps acting off-screen. The strange dog in the woods can belong to the cult. That’s not railroading; it’s the world being alive.

Say this: “Okay, you follow the dog. Meanwhile, back in town, the bell tower has a new lock on it. You’ll hear about that later.”

For a prep routine that fits in an evening, see how to prep a session in under an hour.

2. “No” slips out when “yes, but” would cost nothing

What it looks like: A player asks to swing from the chandelier or talk the guard into a bet, and you say no because it isn’t on your prep page or the rules don’t spell it out.

The fix: Default to yes, then decide how. Three options cover almost everything:

The rules back this up. In both PHBs, you call for an ability check only when the outcome is uncertain. The usual DCs are 10 for easy, 15 for medium and 20 for hard. If nobody is pressuring the character and failure changes nothing, skip the roll.

Say this: “You can try. It’s a Strength (Athletics) check, and if you miss, you land prone in front of the ogre.”

3. Secret dice-fudging becomes your safety blanket

What it looks like: You lower monster damage behind the screen every fight. Nothing ever really threatens the party, and sharp players notice that the dice don’t seem to matter.

The fix: The DMG treats rolling in the open or behind a screen as your call, so this is a style choice, not a rules question. Our advice is to fudge rarely, if at all, and fix the cause instead of the roll:

Rolling big attacks in the open tells the table that their wins are real.

Say this: “I’m rolling this one where you can see it. It’s the dragon’s breath.”

4. You love your NPCs more than the party’s choices

What it looks like: Your villain gives a three-minute monologue. Your favorite NPC solves the puzzle. The players watch.

The fix: The player characters are the protagonists. Use NPCs to put pressure on them, not to replace them:

If you need a believable person in ten seconds, our NPC in a Hurry tool gives you a name, a want and a quirk.

Say this before each session (to yourself): “What does each character want next, and which scene forces them to choose?“

5. Every rules hiccup feels like a crisis

What it looks like: A question comes up about grappling or cover, and the table spends ten minutes with three books open while the fight goes cold.

The fix: Make a ruling in about thirty seconds, write it down, and look it up after the session. Both DMGs present the DM as the one who makes rulings when the rules are unclear. Your fastest tool is advantage or disadvantage: the PHB uses it for exactly these situations, where circumstances help or hinder a roll.

A rules checklist for your first few sessions:

Keeping the rules you look up most on a DM screen turns a lot of those thirty seconds into five.

Say this: “I’ll rule it this way for now. I’ll check after the session, and if I’m wrong, it goes your way next time.”

6. You confuse mystery with starvation

What it looks like: You hold back details so players can “discover” the world, but they can’t see enough to make a choice. They stare at you, then at each other, then someone suggests checking their phone.

The fix: Tell players what their characters would reasonably notice, and give them something to do with it.

Say this: “You’ve searched the study. You found the torn letter and the muddy boots. What do you want to do?“

7. You assume silence means everyone’s happy

What it looks like: One player stops showing up as often. Another hasn’t spoken in an hour. Nobody complains, so you think it’s fine.

The fix: Ask, briefly, on a schedule. People put up with an awkward table for a long time before they say anything.

Many of these problems can be headed off before play starts with a proper session zero. See Session Zero for Dungeon Masters, or use the Session Zero Wizard to build the agreement with your players.

A bonus slip: fights that are too easy or too hard

New DMs often eyeball encounters. The 2014 DMG uses XP thresholds per character plus a multiplier for groups of monsters. The 2024 DMG simplifies this into an XP budget per character for Low, Moderate and High difficulty, with no multiplier. Either one beats guessing. Our encounter generator does the math, and how to balance encounters in 5e explains both systems. For big set pieces, see how to run a boss fight.

Quick reference: mistakes and fixes

MistakeFix to try next session
Prepping a fixed plotWrite who wants what, and what happens if the party does nothing
Saying noYes, yes with a roll, or yes with a cost
Fudging every fightRoll big moments in the open; fix encounter math instead
NPCs stealing scenesThree sentences, then hand it back to a player
Rules freezesRule in 30 seconds, advantage or disadvantage, check later
Withholding informationDescribe exits and points of interest; three clues per conclusion
Assuming everyone’s happyAsk what’s working after session one

A line you can keep in your pocket

You won’t be a flawless DM at session one. Nobody is. If you want something to repeat to yourself before you sit down:

I’ll prep flexible situations, say yes to fun, protect the stakes, serve the heroes’ choices, keep the game moving, and ask how it’s landing.

Small habits beat big speeches. For the next step, read how to be a better Dungeon Master.

Frequently asked questions

What is the biggest mistake new DMs make?

Prepping a fixed plot and then forcing the players back onto it. Prep a situation instead: the people involved, what they want, and what happens if the party does nothing. Then react to what the players choose.

Is it okay for a DM to fudge dice rolls?

The Dungeon Master's Guide leaves it up to the DM, and some tables are fine with it. As advice, fudge rarely if at all. Rolling important attacks in the open builds trust and keeps the stakes real.

What should a new DM do when they don't know a rule?

Make a quick ruling that seems fair, tell the table you'll check it later, and keep playing. Granting advantage or disadvantage is the rules' own tool for unclear situations. Look it up after the session and tell everyone what you found.

How much should a new DM prep?

Usually one to two hours for a three to four hour session is plenty: a strong opening scene, two or three likely locations, a few NPCs with goals, one or two encounters and some names to improvise with.

How do I stop players from derailing my campaign?

Treat the derail as information about what they find interesting. Connect the new thread to your situation, let the villain keep acting off-screen, and talk at session zero about what kind of campaign everyone wants.

Useful at the table

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. More about this.

← All articles

Free: Class Quick Reference

All 12 Player's Handbook classes on one printable page each: levels 1 to 5, subclasses, a standard array and the mistakes new players make. Leave your email and the 12-page PDF is yours, plus the occasional new guide.