What Three Years of D&D Taught Me, as DM and Player
22 October 2026
My name is Thijs Mennen and I’ve been playing D&D since 2023. In that time I’ve switched back and forth between writing stories as a DM and playing a string of different characters. The best part of that is that I could take everything I learned behind the screen into every character I played afterwards.
My last character, Kael, sadly died last session. His arrogance landed him right in the middle of a group of enemies, which is not a great place to be when you are anything but a hero in close combat. So right now I’m building a new character, and honestly it feels like walking into a candy shop for the first time. All that enthusiasm and the urge to play come rushing back.
How our table changed
The thing I enjoy most is how much we’ve changed as players. In the beginning we only looked at what was obvious: there’s an enemy, so we hit it. These days we’re always hunting for other ways to reach our goal. That goes from throwing each other across rooftops to intimidating or seducing our opponents into doing what we want.
It sounds like a small shift, but it changes the whole game. The DM can’t predict us anymore, and we can’t predict each other either. That’s exactly when the best moments happen.
Two moments I’ll never forget
As a DM: the girl in the dark
My party was on a ship full of enemies and they were cutting through all of them. Then they opened a door in the hold. They expected a boss and a final fight. Instead they walked into a huge ballroom, filled with darkness, with one small figure standing in the middle of it.
When they looked closer, they found a girl called Lola, trapped inside the darkness. Freeing her didn’t cost them a single hit point, arrow or spell slot. What saved Lola was empathy: they had to make her feel safe. Only later did they find out that Lola wasn’t a girl on the ship at all. Lola was the ship.
That session taught me that the moment players are ready for a fight is the perfect moment to give them something else entirely.
As a player: the dragon nobody saw coming
We were fighting a group of guards and we were losing, badly. Just before that fight we’d met a dragon. Then one of the other players simply left the fight. At the time that was incredibly frustrating: we were already losing, and now we had one fewer person to do it with.
Two turns later, that player came back. With the dragon. The dragon helped us win, and we could carry on with the story. I still think about how angry I was for those two turns, and how wrong I was.
Three lessons for other players
- Don’t be afraid to dive fully into your character. Your friends stay your friends, even when your character has no bond at all with theirs. Playing a character who clashes with the party is fine, as long as everyone at the table is having fun. If you need help finding the voice, our guide on how to roleplay your character has some good starting points.
- Look for another way. When it’s possible, give yourself and your party the time to look at all your options and think outside the box. It makes the game more exciting and more fun, for the players and for the DM.
- Always have something up your sleeve. Sometimes you just roll three 2s in a row. If you have a way to do things differently, a spell, an item, a skill, a friend you can throw, you won’t be stuck in the same situation or the same fight for ages.
A tip for DMs
Make your fights dynamic and exciting, and let things happen during the fight. If the party is fighting a huge monster in a big cave, let chunks of rock fall from the ceiling. The players have to dive out of the way, and afterwards they can use those rocks as cover. One falling rock does more for a fight than ten extra hit points on the monster. For more ideas, see how to run a boss fight.
And now, back to that candy shop. I’ve got a character to build.
— Thijs Mennen
Useful at the table
- Player's Handbook (2024) The full rules text when a ruling needs settling.
- A good polyhedral dice set Every d4 to d20 you need, and a second set for advantage rolls.
- Wet-erase battle mat Draw cover, terrain and reach in seconds.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. More about this.