Crafting magic items with Xanathar's Guide
Xanathar's Guide to Everything (pages 128 to 129) treats crafting a magic item as a downtime project that also drives adventures. The crafter needs a formula for the item, an exotic material that the party has to go and get, the gold for everything else, and either proficiency with the tool you would use to make the mundane version of the item or proficiency in the Arcana skill.
| Rarity | Workweeks | Cost | Ingredient CR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Common | 1 | 50 gp | 1-3 |
| Uncommon | 2 | 200 gp | 4-8 |
| Rare | 10 | 2,000 gp | 9-12 |
| Very rare | 25 | 20,000 gp | 13-18 |
| Legendary | 50 | 100,000 gp | 19+ |
Halve the time and cost for a consumable such as a potion. The ingredient CR is a suggestion for the creature the characters must face to get the material; the creature might simply guard the place where it is found. A workweek is five days of work. Potions of healing and spell scrolls have their own cheaper rules, which the calculator also covers.
Complications: there is a 10 percent chance of a complication for every five workweeks spent on a magic item, and a 10 percent chance for every workweek spent scribing a scroll. Use the button to roll on the matching Xanathar's d6 table, or invent your own; several entries are a good excuse to bring back a rival.
The 2024 crafting rules
The 2024 Dungeon Master's Guide uses days instead of workweeks (5, 10, 50, 125 and 250 days by rarity, at the same gold costs) and drops the exotic ingredient and complication rolls. The crafter and every assistant need proficiency in Arcana and with the tool for the item's category, for example Jeweler's Tools for rings, Woodcarver's Tools for rods, staffs and wands, Calligrapher's Supplies for scrolls and Alchemist's Supplies or an Herbalism Kit for potions. If the item lets you cast spells, you must have those spells prepared every day you work on it. Magic armor and weapons also cost the price of the mundane item, or you can craft that item yourself with the Player's Handbook rules.
The 2024 Player's Handbook covers the cheap stuff: a Potion of Healing takes an Herbalism Kit, 25 GP and one day, and spell scrolls have their own table. To scribe a scroll you need proficiency in Arcana or with Calligrapher's Supplies, the spell prepared every day, and any Material components; components the spell consumes are used up when the scroll is finished. The scroll uses your spell save DC and attack bonus.
Using it at the table
Set the item, copy the summary and paste it in your group chat or campaign notes. Track the downtime between sessions; our guide to prepping a session in under an hour has tips on fitting downtime in. Looking for the exotic ingredient's guardian? Build the fight with the encounter generator. And if crafting takes too long, the magic shop generator prices items by the same rarities, while the treasure hoard generator hands them out as loot.
Frequently asked questions
How long does it take to craft a magic item in 5e?
With Xanathar's Guide it takes 1 workweek and 50 gp for a common item, 2 workweeks and 200 gp for uncommon, 10 workweeks and 2,000 gp for rare, 25 workweeks and 20,000 gp for very rare and 50 workweeks and 100,000 gp for legendary. Consumables take half the time and cost. The 2024 DMG uses days instead: 5, 10, 50, 125 and 250 days for the same costs.
What does a character need to craft a magic item with Xanathar's rules?
A formula for the item, an exotic material that usually comes from facing a creature of a suggested challenge rating, the gold for other materials, and either proficiency with the right tool or proficiency in the Arcana skill. The time is spent as downtime.
What does a character need under the 2024 rules?
Proficiency in Arcana and proficiency with the tool for the item's category, such as Jeweler's Tools for a ring or Woodcarver's Tools for a wand. Any spells the item lets you cast must be prepared on every day of crafting. The DM decides whether raw materials are available: a 75 percent chance in a city and 25 percent in other settlements.
How much does it cost to scribe a spell scroll?
Xanathar's Guide: 15 gp for a cantrip and 25 gp for a 1st-level spell (1 day each), up to 250,000 gp and 48 workweeks for a 9th-level spell. The 2024 Player's Handbook is much cheaper at higher levels: 1,500 GP and 25 days for 5th level, 50,000 GP and 120 days for 9th level.
How often do crafting complications happen?
In Xanathar's Guide there is a 10 percent chance of a complication for every five workweeks spent crafting a magic item, and a 10 percent chance for every workweek spent scribing a spell scroll. The 2024 rules have no complication roll. The calculator shows how many rolls you need and the chance that at least one complication happens.
Can other characters help craft a magic item?
Under the 2024 DMG, yes: divide the crafting time by the number of characters working on it. Normally only one other character can assist, but the DM might allow more, and every helper needs the same proficiencies. Xanathar's Guide allows helpers for ordinary crafting but doesn't say whether they speed up magic items, so that is the DM's call.