Advantage and Disadvantage in D&D 5e Explained

Printable: all 15 conditions, saving throws, actions, rests and cover on 7 illustrated cheat sheet pages. Get the PDF ($4.99)

You’ve felt it in your hands before the math even lands: the DM says “with advantage,” and you reach for a second d20 like it’s luck’s spare key. Disadvantage is the opposite muscle memory: two dice, take the low, and suddenly the room feels tight.

These two rules are fifth edition’s replacement for long lists of tiny situational modifiers. Once you know the cancelling rule, you’ll read combat and exploration scenes faster, and you’ll spot when your party can create advantage on purpose.

Free tool: plug in your attack bonus and the target’s AC in the hit chance calculator and toggle advantage to see your real odds.


The core rule (attacks, saves, checks)

Then add your modifiers to the one die you kept, exactly as you would with a single roll. It works on all three kinds of d20 roll: attack rolls, ability checks and saving throws (the 2024 rules call these “D20 Tests”). It never applies to damage dice, hit point rolls or other non-d20 rolls.

Worked example

Your fighter has +5 to hit and the orc has AC 15, so you need a 10 or higher on the die. You attack with advantage and roll a 7 and a 13. You keep the 13: 13 + 5 = 18, a hit. With disadvantage, you’d keep the 7: 12, a miss.


The odds: how much is advantage worth?

Advantage isn’t a flat bonus. Its value depends on what you need to roll. It’s worth the most when you need around an 11, and the least at the edges.

You need on the d20NormalAdvantageDisadvantage
2+95%99.75%90.25%
6+75%93.75%56.25%
11+50%75%25%
16+25%43.75%6.25%
20 only5%9.75%0.25%

In the middle of the table, advantage is worth about +5; averaged over all targets, it’s closer to +3.3. Disadvantage is the mirror image.

The extremes move the most:

That’s why rogues hunting a crit and paladins saving Smites for a crit both love advantage. More on that in critical hits.


Stacking and cancelling (the rule that ends bonus-hunting)

So one source of disadvantage undoes three sources of advantage. The rules do this on purpose: nobody has to count sources.

Worked example

Your rogue is hidden (advantage), the target is prone and you’re next to it (advantage), and an ally used Help on it (advantage). But you’re poisoned (disadvantage). Result: one normal d20. If the poison ends, you’re back to two dice, not four.


Common advantage sources

Common disadvantage sources


Passive scores with advantage or disadvantage

Passive scores (most famously passive Perception) don’t roll dice, so the rule converts:

Example: Wisdom 14 (+2) and proficiency in Perception (+2) at low level gives passive Perception 14. With advantage it’s 19; in dim light without darkvision, Perception checks that rely on sight have disadvantage, so it drops to 9. More in passive Perception.


Rerolls, Lucky and other edge cases

Rerolling with advantage: the 2014 PHB says that if you have advantage or disadvantage and something lets you reroll the d20, you reroll only one of the dice, and you choose which.

Halfling Lucky: if you roll a 1 on one of your two dice, you can reroll that die. Same principle.

Initiative: it’s a Dexterity check, so advantage applies. In 2024, the Invisible condition grants advantage on initiative, and surprise gives disadvantage on it.

Death saving throws: these are saving throws, but they aren’t tied to an ability, so features that give advantage on, say, Dexterity saves don’t apply. See death saving throws.

Advantage plus a bonus die: Bless, Bardic Inspiration and guidance add on top. Roll your two d20s, keep one, then add the extra die.


2014 vs 2024: what changed

The core rule is identical in both rulebooks: two dice, keep high or low, no stacking, any mix cancels. What changed are some sources:

Topic2014 PHB2024 PHB
Exhaustion level 1Disadvantage on ability checksNo disadvantage; each level is -2 to all D20 Tests
SurpriseCan’t act on your first turnDisadvantage on initiative
InvisibleAdvantage on your attacks, disadvantage on attacks against youSame, plus advantage on initiative
Help (attack)Helper within 5 ft of the targetHelper picks an enemy within 5 ft of themselves
Heroic InspirationAdvantage on one roll (DM award)Reroll any one die, keep the new roll

The last row matters: 2014 Inspiration grants advantage, but 2024 Heroic Inspiration is a reroll and never gives advantage.


Table habits that make advantage work


Why the design still feels good a hundred sessions later

Older editions loved stacking small modifiers, and tables bogged down in arithmetic. Advantage and disadvantage are fast, readable and hard to rules-lawyer into infinity. They say “the situation matters” without a spreadsheet.

Related systems you’ll use constantly: how combat works, saving throws and initiative.

Frequently asked questions

What does advantage mean in D&D 5e?

You roll two d20s and use the higher result. It applies to attack rolls, ability checks and saving throws, and roughly equals a +3 to +5 bonus in the middle of the range.

Do advantage and disadvantage stack?

No. Multiple sources of advantage still give you two dice, not three. If you have at least one source of each, they cancel and you roll one d20, no matter how many sources are on each side.

How much does advantage increase your chance to crit?

From 5% to 9.75% with a normal crit range. If you crit on a 19 or 20, advantage raises it from 10% to 19%.

Does advantage apply to damage rolls?

No. Advantage and disadvantage only affect d20 rolls: attack rolls, ability checks and saving throws. Damage dice are rolled normally.

What is advantage worth on passive Perception?

Add 5 to the passive score for advantage and subtract 5 for disadvantage. A passive Perception of 14 becomes 19 with advantage or 9 with disadvantage.

Can you have advantage on initiative?

Yes. Initiative is a Dexterity check, so effects that give advantage on it, or on Dexterity checks in general, apply. In the 2024 rules the Invisible condition also gives advantage on initiative.

Useful at the table

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. More about this.

← All articles

Free: Class Quick Reference

All 12 Player's Handbook classes on one printable page each: levels 1 to 5, subclasses, a standard array and the mistakes new players make. Leave your email and the 12-page PDF is yours, plus the occasional new guide.