Critical Hits 5e: Nat 20 Damage, Auto-Crits, and Common Mistakes
16 May 2026
Printable: all 15 conditions, saving throws, actions, rests and cover on 7 illustrated cheat sheet pages. Get the PDF ($4.99)
A critical hit is the table’s applause cue. The fighter rolls a natural 20, everyone leans in, and suddenly you’re rolling a fistful of damage dice. It’s a simple rule, right up until someone tries to double their +5 too, or asks whether the Sneak Attack dice count.
This guide covers the exact rule, what doubles and what doesn’t, automatic crits, features that widen your crit range, crits at 0 hit points, a worked example and the 2024 changes. For the bigger picture of attacking, see how D&D combat works.
Free tool: the hit chance calculator shows your crit chance with advantage, Elven Accuracy and an expanded crit range.
The critical hit rule (2014 PHB)
- Natural 20 on an attack roll: the attack hits regardless of modifiers or AC, and it’s a critical hit.
- Damage: roll all of the attack’s damage dice twice and add them together. Then add any relevant modifiers as normal, once.
- Natural 1: the attack misses regardless of modifiers or AC. There’s no fumble table in the core rules.
- Attacks only. The crit rule applies to attack rolls, both weapon and spell attacks. It doesn’t apply to saving throws or ability checks.
What doubles and what doesn’t
| Damage source | Doubled on a crit? |
|---|---|
| Weapon damage dice (1d8 longsword → 2d8) | Yes |
| Spell attack dice (fire bolt, guiding bolt, inflict wounds) | Yes |
| Sneak Attack dice | Yes |
| Divine Smite dice (declared after you see the hit) | Yes |
| Hex and hunter’s mark extra d6 | Yes, they’re part of the attack’s damage |
| Ability modifier (+3, +4, +5) | No |
| Flat bonuses (+10 Great Weapon Master, +2 Dueling, +1 magic weapon) | No |
| Damage from a save-based spell (fireball) | No, it can’t crit |
| Magic missile | No, it doesn’t use an attack roll |
The general test: if the dice are rolled as part of this attack’s damage, they double. If a number is a flat bonus, it doesn’t.
Automatic critical hits
Two conditions turn any hit into a crit:
- Paralyzed: any attack that hits the creature is a critical hit if the attacker is within 5 feet.
- Unconscious: same rule.
Attacks against these creatures also have advantage, so they hit often. They still need to hit: a miss is still a miss. The 5-foot rule is about the attacker’s distance, so a crossbow shot from 5 feet away also crits.
This is why hold person on a humanoid followed by the party’s melee characters is one of the strongest combos at low levels.
Features that crit more often or harder (2014)
| Feature | Effect |
|---|---|
| Champion fighter, Improved Critical (3rd level) | Weapon attacks crit on a 19 or 20 |
| Champion fighter, Superior Critical (15th level) | Weapon attacks crit on an 18 to 20 |
| Half-orc, Savage Attacks | One extra weapon damage die on a melee weapon crit |
| Barbarian, Brutal Critical (9th level) | One extra weapon damage die on a melee crit; two at 13th, three at 17th |
| Advantage | Roughly doubles your crit chance: 5% becomes about 9.75% |
For how advantage changes the odds, see advantage and disadvantage.
A worked example
A 5th-level paladin (longsword, Strength +4) hits an ogre with a natural 20 and uses Divine Smite with a 1st-level slot (2d8 radiant).
- Normal hit with smite: 1d8 + 2d8 + 4. Average 4.5 + 9 + 4 = 17.5.
- Critical hit with smite: 2d8 + 4d8 + 4. Average 9 + 18 + 4 = 31.
Because paladins choose to smite after they know the attack hit, many save their slots for crits. That’s a legitimate tactic.
Same idea for a 5th-level rogue with a shortsword (1d6 + 3) and 3d6 Sneak Attack: a crit is 8d6 + 3, averaging 31.
Crits and 0 hit points
Crits matter for dying characters too:
- If you take any damage while at 0 hit points, you suffer a death save failure. If it’s from a critical hit, you suffer two failures.
- Melee attacks against an unconscious character from within 5 feet are automatic crits, so one hit from an adjacent monster is two failures.
- Rolling a natural 20 on a death saving throw isn’t a crit, but it’s special: you regain 1 hit point and wake up.
More in death saving throws.
What changed in the 2024 rules
The core rule is the same: a 20 on the d20 for an attack roll is a critical hit, you roll the attack’s damage dice twice and add modifiers once, and attacks that hit a paralyzed or unconscious target from within 5 feet are critical hits. The Champion still crits on 19 to 20 from 3rd level. The barbarian’s Brutal Critical was replaced by a different feature (Brutal Strike), and the 2024 Orc species doesn’t have Savage Attacks. Divine Smite became a spell you cast right after hitting, and its dice still double on a crit.
Common mistakes
- Doubling modifiers. Double the dice, add modifiers once.
- Rolling dice and then doubling the total. Mathematically close, but the rule is to roll twice as many dice. Some tables use “max one set, roll the other” as a house rule; agree on it first.
- Forgetting the extra dice. Sneak Attack, smite, hex and hunter’s mark all double.
- Critting on saves. A natural 20 on a Dexterity save against fireball is just a high roll.
- Treating a natural 20 on a skill check as automatic success. That’s a popular house rule, not a core rule.
- Missing the auto-crit. Every hit from 5 feet on a paralyzed or unconscious creature is a crit, not just natural 20s.
Table speed tip
Say it out loud: “Crit, double dice.” Grab twice the dice, roll them together, add your modifier once. If you’re a rogue or paladin, put your Sneak Attack or smite dice in the same pile so nothing gets forgotten.
Related reading: Sneak Attack, paralyzed condition, spell attacks vs saving throws.
Frequently asked questions
What is a critical hit in D&D 5e?
When you roll a 20 on the d20 for an attack roll, the attack hits regardless of the target's AC and is a critical hit. You roll all of the attack's damage dice twice and add your modifiers once.
Do you double modifiers on a crit?
No. Only dice are doubled. Your Strength or Dexterity modifier and other flat bonuses, like the +10 from Great Weapon Master, are added once.
Does Sneak Attack double on a critical hit?
Yes. Sneak Attack dice are part of the attack's damage, so they're rolled twice. A 5th-level rogue's 3d6 Sneak Attack becomes 6d6.
Can spells score critical hits?
Spells that use an attack roll, like fire bolt or guiding bolt, can crit on a natural 20 and double their dice. Spells that use a saving throw, like fireball, or that hit automatically, like magic missile, can't crit.
Do attacks against an unconscious creature always crit?
Any attack that hits an unconscious or paralyzed creature is a critical hit if the attacker is within 5 feet. The attack still has to hit, though it has advantage.
What happens if you take a critical hit while at 0 hit points?
You suffer two death saving throw failures instead of one. If the damage equals or exceeds your hit point maximum, you die outright.
Useful at the table
- Wet-erase battle mat Draw cover, terrain and reach in seconds.
- Painted miniatures Makes positioning, reach and flanking obvious at a glance.
- A good polyhedral dice set Every d4 to d20 you need, and a second set for advantage rolls.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. More about this.