Spell Attacks vs Saving Throws 5e: Who Rolls and Which Is Better

Printable: all 15 conditions, saving throws, actions, rests and cover on 7 illustrated cheat sheet pages. Get the PDF ($4.99)

Every caster eventually asks the same question: “Do I roll, or do they?” That split is the backbone of 5e spell design. Get it once and reading spell cards becomes muscle memory, and choosing between two spells against a specific monster stops being a guess.

This guide covers both systems in the 2014 rules, the few 2024 changes worth knowing, a worked example with real hit chances, and the mistakes that cost casters damage every session. For slots and casting basics, start with how spellcasting works. For the six defenses themselves, see saving throws explained.

Free tools: get your numbers from the spell save DC calculator, then compare odds in the hit chance calculator.


The two systems at a glance

Spell attackSaving throw spell
Who rollsThe casterThe target
Compared againstTarget’s ACCaster’s spell save DC
Natural 20Critical hit, double damage diceNo special effect
On a “miss”Usually nothingOften half damage, or no effect
Advantage comes fromProne (melee), restrained, blinded or unseen targets, attacking while hiddenDisadvantage on the target’s save (restrained gives it on Dex saves)
Can a target auto-fail?NoParalyzed, stunned, petrified and unconscious creatures auto-fail Strength and Dexterity saves
Legendary ResistanceDoesn’t applyCan turn a failure into a success
Typical examplesFire bolt, eldritch blast, guiding bolt, scorching rayFireball, hold person, web, banishment, sacred flame

Spell attack rolls in detail

A spell attack is an attack roll, so everything that affects attack rolls affects it:


Saving throw spells in detail

The spell names the ability and tells you what happens on a failure and a success. Read the exact line: some spells deal half damage on a success (fireball, lightning bolt), others do nothing on a success (hold person, toll the dead).


What changed in the 2024 rules

The formulas are identical in the 2024 Player’s Handbook. A few individual spells switched systems, so check the version your table uses:


Worked example: fire bolt vs fireball vs hold person

You play a level 5 wizard with Intelligence 18 (+4) and proficiency bonus +3.

Target 1: an ogre (AC 11, Dexterity 8, Wisdom 7, no save proficiencies).

Target 2: a knight (AC 18 in plate, Dexterity +0, Wisdom save +2, Constitution save +4).

Against the ogre, the attack cantrip is the most reliable tool. Against the knight, the same cantrip drops to a coin flip, while save spells barely notice the plate armor. That is the whole decision in one picture: look at what the target is good at, then use the other system.


How to choose: a quick guide

SituationUsually better
Heavily armored enemy (plate, shield, high AC)Saves, especially Wisdom, Intelligence or Charisma
Big, slow brute (ogre, giant, many beasts)Attacks, or Dexterity and mental saves
Agile skirmisher (high Dex, low Con)Constitution saves, or attacks if its AC is low
Boss with Legendary ResistanceAttack spells and damage, save effects after resistances are spent
Clustered group of weak enemiesArea saves like fireball or web
Target is prone, restrained or blindedAttacks gain advantage (prone only helps within 5 feet)
You are in melee with a ranged-only kitSave spells, or step away before casting

A good rule for building a spell list: carry one reliable attack cantrip and one save cantrip (for example fire bolt and toll the dead), and spread your leveled save spells across different abilities so one strong save doesn’t shut you out.


Common mistakes


Quick read of a spell card

  1. Range and target line. Humanoid only? Creature you can see?
  2. Attack roll or save? And which ability?
  3. Effect on a hit or failed save, and on a success.
  4. Concentration and duration. See concentration explained.
  5. Components. Do you have a free hand? See spell components.

If an enemy caster is the problem, remember that Counterspell stops the casting itself, whether the spell would have used an attack roll or a save.

Not sure what your own numbers are? How to calculate attack bonus and spell save DC has the formulas and worked examples.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a spell attack and a saving throw in 5e?

With a spell attack, the caster rolls d20 plus their spell attack modifier against the target's Armor Class. With a saving throw spell, the target rolls d20 plus their save bonus against the caster's spell save DC. The spell description tells you which one it uses.

How do you calculate spell attack bonus and spell save DC?

Spell attack bonus equals your spellcasting ability modifier plus your proficiency bonus. Spell save DC equals 8 plus your proficiency bonus plus your spellcasting ability modifier. Some magic items raise them: a wand of the war mage adds to spell attack rolls, and a rod of the pact keeper adds to both.

Can saving throw spells critically hit?

No. Critical hits only happen on attack rolls. A natural 20 or natural 1 on a saving throw has no special effect in the core rules, so save spells never deal double damage.

Is a spell attack or a saving throw spell better?

Neither is always better. Attack spells do well against low AC and can crit, while save spells shine against a weak saving throw and often deal half damage even when the target succeeds. Most casters want at least one of each.

Does cover affect spell attacks and saving throws?

Half cover gives +2 and three-quarters cover gives +5 to AC, which hurts spell attacks. The same bonus applies to Dexterity saving throws against effects that originate on the other side of the cover. Spells like sacred flame ignore cover entirely.

Do I have disadvantage on ranged spell attacks in melee?

Yes. A ranged spell attack, like fire bolt or eldritch blast, has disadvantage if a hostile creature that can see you and isn't incapacitated is within 5 feet of you. Saving throw spells don't have this problem.

Useful at the table

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases, at no extra cost to you. More about this.

← All articles

Free: Class Quick Reference

All 12 Player's Handbook classes on one printable page each: levels 1 to 5, subclasses, a standard array and the mistakes new players make. Leave your email and the 12-page PDF is yours, plus the occasional new guide.